A Couple Buy a Wedding Gift for Themselves: A House on Long Island. Which One Did They Choose? – The New York Times

The Hunt
Aug. 18, 2022
With extra cash from their fall wedding, two newlyweds left the city and searched Nassau County for a house fit for a family and a 75-pound dog. Here’s what they found.
Allie Rose and Thomas Bundy are traditionalists, and their house search reads like a riff on the old adage: First comes love, then comes marriage, then comes the house with the ample garage.
“We’re kind of straight and narrow,” said Ms. Rose, a lawyer. “The idea of getting married and then buying a house was ingrained in us.”
The couple, both 28, got an early start on the plan: They grew up in Mount Sinai, on the North Shore of Long Island, went to high school together and started dating when they were 15. When they married last October, they were renting a two-bedroom apartment on the third floor of a walk-up in Park Slope, Brooklyn. After they returned from their honeymoon, they began looking for a house in the suburbs.
They had spent a year and a half in Brooklyn working from home at side-by-side desks squeezed into the living room. Mr. Bundy, a software engineer, was tired of parking his car on the street and constantly moving it. And during the summers, they hated struggling with costly window air-conditioning units. But their top priority was finding a yard for Simba, their 75-pound golden retriever.
“What’s that joke? ‘Happy wife, happy life?’” Ms. Rose said. “For us, it’s about a happy dog.”
[Did you recently buy or rent a home in the New York metro area? We want to hear from you. Email: thehunt@nytimes.com]
While home for Christmas in December, the couple contacted Andrea Reich, an agent with Realty Connect USA, and started going to open houses near where they grew up — although in Nassau County, a little closer to the city, rather than Suffolk.
“It was a logical decision rather than an emotional one,” Ms. Rose said of returning to Long Island. “It was definitely a conversation of being closer to family and making things easier.”
With up to $900,000 to spend, they knew they would need a mortgage. But they had a down payment on hand. “It was going to be paid for out of pretty much all the money we received from our wedding,” Mr. Bundy said. They were also able to use some extra cash from Ms. Rose, whose student-loan payments were paused in March 2020.
As they hunted, New York was being walloped by Omicron, and Covid-19 precautions meant they had to wait outside in line, often in freezing temperatures, as sellers allowed two or three potential buyers in at a time.
But Ms. Reich urged them to see every property they were interested in, because listings can be deceiving and calling ahead to ask questions was often not an option. “Agents were so overwhelmed that we couldn’t necessarily get through to people, and even with texting, get people to get back to you in a timely fashion,” she said.
Among the properties they saw:
No. 1
Five Bedrooms in Bellmore
This five-bedroom, two-bathroom house was built in 1964 and recently renovated. There was a breakfast nook in the ample kitchen, central air-conditioning, a formal living and dining room, a one-car garage and a big fenced backyard for Simba. Despite showing the house in January, the sellers wanted to stay until August — an issue for the couple, whose lease was up in June. The asking price was $799,000, with annual taxes of about $14,000.
No. 2
Good Fit in Mineola
This renovated 1959 house, with four bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms, felt like the right size. It had a fully finished basement, a two-car garage and a freshly updated kitchen with quartz countertops and stainless steel appliances. But the second floor needed separate air-conditioning units, and the backyard felt a bit small. The asking price was $899,099, with taxes of about $10,000.
No. 3
Split-Level in Seaford
This renovated split-level 1956 house, with four bedrooms and three bathrooms, was on a cul-de-sac. It had heated floors, an eat-in kitchen with a farm sink and quartz counters, a finished basement and a two-car garage. The main bedroom suite was on a separate level, with crown molding and a cathedral ceiling. There was a stone patio in the fenced backyard. The asking price was $775,000, with annual taxes of about $12,000.
Find out what happened next by answering these two questions:
Which Would You Choose?
Five Bedrooms in Bellmore
Good Fit in Mineola
Split-Level in Seaford
Which Did They Choose?
Five Bedrooms in Bellmore
Good Fit in Mineola
Split-Level in Seaford
A Sturdy Starter Apartment: Scarred by her experience of renting in a brand-new building, a first-time buyer looked at “nice old apartments” in Brooklyn. Here’s where she landed.
A Comfortable Pied-à-Terre: A couple based in the Catskills could afford up to $400,000 for a place to stay when in the city. Here are the options they found.
Converted Industrial Spaces: After an impulsive move from California, a New York newcomer tested her $1.8 million budget in Manhattan’s loft-filled neighborhoods.
An Upper-West-Side Romance: After college, Lily Kaplan watched her friends leave the neighborhood in favor of cheaper rents. She stuck it out, and found a studio she loves.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *